Stock, bond or sukuk: what do you hold?
Halal Bourse · October 4, 2026 · Understanding
Partner, creditor or co-owner: a report on a 2023 Moroccan study.
Idrīs Aït Mālik, a doctoral student in Islamic sciences in Casablanca, published a study in Arabic in the journal al-Maʿrifa (No. 11) in December 2023: “Stocks, Bonds and Sukuk, and Their Rulings According to Ijtihād.” We report on it in our own words, without translating it.
The author recalls that the Law lets everyone earn money and asks only where it comes from. He then examines three instruments that many people confuse.
The stock: a share of ownership
Contemporary scholars have debated the nature of the stock. Some see it as a commodity that is bought and sold, without regard to what it represents. Others, with whom the author sides, see it as the partner's share in the company's assets. He gives two arguments. The shareholder can sell or give away his stock, so he owns something. And he receives his share of the assets when the partners liquidate the company.
The shareholder is therefore a partner. He earns if the company earns and receives nothing if it loses.
The bond: an interest-bearing loan
A bond is a debt security. Its holder lends to a company or a state, which pays him an income fixed in advance, profit or no profit. The author reports three views.
- The great majority of scholars prohibit all interest-bearing bonds, whatever they are called. The International Islamic Fiqh Academy, meeting in Jeddah in March 1990, issued the same ruling.
- A few authors permit them: they say this contract did not exist at the time of the Revelation, or that it resembles a partnership.
- Others permit only prize bonds, which replace interest with a draw.
The author holds to the prohibition. The issuer of a bond borrows and commits to repay more: scholars agree in prohibiting this surplus. The holder shares neither profit nor loss, so he is in no way a partner. The Academy and AAOIFI also prohibit prize bonds.
The sukuk: a share of real assets
The holder of a sukuk owns an undivided share of a project or a real asset. The study recalls the rules that follow.
- The holder shares in the profit and bears the loss, in proportion to his share.
- The issuer promises him neither a fixed amount nor a percentage of the face value.
- The manager guarantees neither the capital nor the profit, unless he is at fault.
- The issuer buys the sukuk back at its market value or at a price agreed on the day of repurchase, never at its face value.
- Resale follows what the sukuk contains: the rules of currency exchange if it still represents only money, those of debt if it represents receivables, a free price if it mainly represents goods and usufructs.
What you are
With a stock, you are a partner. With a bond, you are a creditor whom the issuer pays in interest. With a sukuk, you are a co-owner and you bear the risk.
On Halal Bourse
The site follows the same framework. It classifies bonds and Treasury bills as “Prohibited” and sukuk backed by real assets as “Permitted.” It judges stocks company by company, based on activity and financial statements.
The study cites the saying “every loan that brings a benefit is riba” as a hadith. Our checks find no authentic chain of transmission for it. The rule stands on the consensus of scholars, which the author also reports.
Sources
- Idrīs Aït Mālik, “al-Ashum wa-l-sanadāt wa-l-ṣukūk wa-aḥkāmuhā wafqa al-ijtihād al-fiqhī,” journal al-Maʿrifa, No. 11, December 2023, p. 185 ff.
- International Islamic Fiqh Academy, resolution No. 60 (6/11) on bonds, Jeddah, March 1990 (text on iifa-aifi.org)
In the same section
- Mixed companies: ʿAlī al-Qaradāghī's argument October 4, 2026
- Quelle action pouvez-vous acheter ? October 4, 2026
- Leaving interest-based finance: the path a Karachi teacher chooses October 4, 2026
- Investing in stocks: the rules of a Saudi sharia committee October 4, 2026
- Strict view, tolerance view: why we show both October 4, 2026
- 30% or one third: where the thresholds come from October 4, 2026
Read in the app · All articles
General information: neither investment advice nor a fatwa. Verdict calculated by published rules, from financial statements read automatically and not reviewed by a human. Read the methodology