Halal Bourse

Home › Blog › Riba

Money in the bank: leave the interest or withdraw it to give it away? Iḥsān al-ʿUtaybī's file

Halal Bourse · October 18, 2026 · Riba

Deposit in an interest-based bank only out of necessity; do not leave the interest to the bank but withdraw it and give it away without benefiting from it, according to Ibn Bāz, Ibn Jibrīn and the Fiqh Academy of India; Ibn ʿUthaymīn refuses to touch it. An account of an exchange published on Ṣayd al-Fawā'id, hadith checked against the source.

The website Ṣayd al-Fawā'id publishes, undated, a written exchange between Iḥsān b. Muḥammad al-ʿUtaybī (Abū Ṭāriq), author of many texts on that site, and other forum participants, under the title “Placing money in the bank, taking the interest on it and disposing of it.” The author reports a session among brothers and the fatwas he found afterwards. It is a preacher's file, not an institutional fatwa. We give an account of it in our own words, and we checked the hadith cited.

Three questions, three answers

The fatwas he cites

Ibn Bāz, according to the collection Fatāwā islāmiyya (2/407): what the bank gave you as profit, do not return it to the bank and do not consume it; spend it on good works, alms to the poor, maintenance of sanitary facilities, help for insolvent debtors. Ibn Jibrīn (2/408-409): depositing in these banks helps them in sin, and he advises against it; someone with no Islamic bank within reach may deposit there and take what they pay, without mixing it with his money, to give it to the poor and to fighters, rather than leaving it to those who will fund churches. To the question “how do I get rid of the interest?”, he answers: withdraw it and allocate it to mosques and schools in Muslim countries that need them, rather than leaving it to the bank's people, who are targeted by the hadith cursing the one who consumes riba and the one who feeds it to others (Muslim 1598, checked).

The author also cites decision no. 5 of the Fiqh Academy of India: leave nothing to the bank; give the interest to the poor without intending a reward; do not allocate it to mosques; the majority allows other charitable works apart from obligatory alms, a minority reserves it for the poor. We reopened neither the collections nor that decision.

An objection: interest resembles found property

One participant, Riḍā Aḥmad Ṣamadī, spells out the reasoning: riba belongs to the one who paid it, and it should be returned to him; but the payer is not the bank, a joint-stock company, but its shareholders and its borrowers, impossible to identify. The interest paid to the customer therefore has the status of found property without an owner. Since banks spend as they please the interest left to them, contemporary scholars have held it prohibited to leave it to them; taking it serves the public interest. He adds that depositing without necessity remains prohibited, that a business's need (letters of guarantee, documentary credits) may stand in for necessity, that one must then prefer an Islamic bank despite its shortcomings, and not exceed strict need.

Ibn ʿUthaymīn touches nothing

The author replies that Ibn ʿUthaymīn departs from this view. According to Fatāwā al-buyūʿ (p. 47), whoever deposits out of necessity takes nothing in return: taking would be riba, and the Quran commands to give up what remains of riba (2:278-279). The author notes that the sheikh gives eight reasons, which he did not copy out.

On the same page: the banks' murābaḥa

The thread continues with a critique of the murābaḥa practiced by so-called Islamic banks, addressed to another participant. The author sees five defects in it: the bank buys from a seller who has already sold to the customer, it earns without ever guaranteeing the goods, it sells without having them in its possession, it opens the door to fictitious invoices, and the whole resembles the tricks of the Banū Isrā'īl. He recalls that al-Albānī and Ibn ʿUthaymīn disputed this arrangement. That second debate belongs to another subject; we note it without developing it.

What you take away

Sources

In the same section

Read in the app · All articles

General information: neither investment advice nor a fatwa. Verdict calculated by published rules, from financial statements read automatically and not reviewed by a human. Read the methodology