Foundations (2/6): three systems, and the question of scarcity
Halal Bourse · October 4, 2026 · Foundations
Capitalism, socialism, the Islamic system: what separates them. Then a debate among Muslim researchers: does scarcity contradict faith?
Second installment of our summary of Dr. Saʿd al-Luḥyānī's textbook, “Principles of Islamic Economics” (Umm al-Qurā University, Mecca).
Three ways to study economics
The author distinguishes the system, the theory, and the policy. The system is the path a society follows in its economic life. It rests on values, and therefore on a worldview. The theory looks for the laws of phenomena: when the price of a good falls, people buy more of it, all else being equal. These laws describe human behavior, and the author judges them less stable than those of physics. Economic policy comprises the measures the state takes: taxes, public spending, credit control.
Capitalism, socialism, the Islamic system
- Capitalism rests on economic freedom and private property. Everyone consumes, saves, and produces as they wish. Public property remains the exception, for goods that no one wants to produce.
- Socialism entrusts the means of production to the state. The plan decides what society produces and how it is distributed. The individual works for the state.
- The Islamic system recognizes economic freedom and sets limits on it, those of the Law. It admits both forms of property, private and public, each in its own domain. The state oversees activity, corrects its disorders, and takes charge of what the general interest entrusts to it, without taking away people's right to undertake ventures.
The author notes a difference of origin. Men wrote the principles of the first two systems. The third is part of the religion: Muslim society is bound to follow it.
The economic problem
Economists start from an observation: needs exceed available resources. They call this relative scarcity. A society must therefore choose. It ranks its needs, serves the most important first, and gives up the others. If everything were available without effort, like air, no one would have to choose, and economic science would have no subject.
Does scarcity contradict faith?
Muslim researchers disagree, and the author sets out the two camps.
The first camp rejects the idea of scarcity. God has guaranteed the sustenance of His creatures and placed on earth the means to feed them. They cite verses 32 to 34 of surah Ibrāhīm (“He gave you of all that you asked of Him”), verse 10 of surah Fuṣṣilat, and verse 6 of surah Hūd: there is no creature on earth whose sustenance is not God's charge.
The second camp holds scarcity to be a fact that does not contradict the creed. They put forward five arguments.
- Other verses speak of measure: “We send it down only in a determined measure” (al-Ḥijr, 21); “If God were to extend provision to His servants, they would commit excesses on earth” (al-Shūrā, 27).
- Islam prohibits waste. This rule presupposes limited resources.
- Baraka is a gift God grants to whom He wills. It would not have this meaning if everyone had everything.
- Observation: no known society has seen all its needs satisfied.
- The rules of property, sharing, and solidarity exist because resources are not enough for everyone.
The author's position
Dr. al-Luḥyānī sides with the second camp. The domain of the permitted is vast, and a Muslim's lawful desires can extend far. He cites verse 32 of surah al-Aʿrāf, on the good things God has produced for His servants.
Scarcity concerns resources that are ready to use. The subsoil and the seas hold riches, but extracting them takes effort, and that effort has its limits. God guaranteed sustenance without delivering it ready-made: “We created man in hardship” (al-Balad, 4). Saying that water is scarce in the desert does not challenge God's decree.
The author adds that Islam narrows the gap between needs and resources from both ends. It disciplines desires, and it urges people to work.
Sources
- Dr. Saʿd b. Ḥamdān al-Luḥyānī, “Mabādi' al-iqtiṣād al-islāmī” (Principles of Islamic Economics), Umm al-Qurā University, 1428 AH, chapters 3 and 4, pp. 17-30 (Arabic text)
- Next installment: production, labor, land, capital, and risk
In the same section
- Foundations (1/6): what is Islamic economics? October 4, 2026
- Foundations (3/6): production, labor, land, capital, and risk October 4, 2026
- Foundations (4/6): how a price is formed October 4, 2026
- Foundations (5/6): money, from gold to banknotes October 4, 2026
- Foundations (6/6): interest-based banking, Islamic banking October 4, 2026
Read in the app · All articles
General information: neither investment advice nor a fatwa. Verdict calculated by published rules, from financial statements read automatically and not reviewed by a human. Read the methodology