Foundations (5/6): money, from gold to banknotes
Halal Bourse · October 4, 2026 · Foundations
From barter to the bank account, the four functions of money, the history of the dinar, and the status of the banknote: riba, zakat, exchange.
Fifth installment of our summary of Dr. Saʿd al-Luḥyānī's textbook, “Principles of Islamic Economics” (Umm al-Qurā University, Mecca).
From barter to money
As long as everyone produced for themselves, no one traded. Specialization changed that: someone who grows only wheat must obtain everything else. Barter then raises three difficulties.
- Each party must want what the other has. The man who has wheat and wants eggs finds a man who has eggs and wants oil.
- Each good has as many prices as there are other goods. Ten goods give forty-five exchange ratios.
- A house cannot be split among ten sellers, and foodstuffs kept in reserve spoil.
Eight stages
Societies first took a commodity as money: cattle, salt, grain. They moved to metals, then to gold and silver, which all peoples accepted. The state struck coins of guaranteed weight and fineness, and people counted instead of weighing. Goldsmiths and banks issued receipts against deposited gold, and these receipts circulated. Banks issued more of them than they held in gold. After bankruptcies, the state reserved issuance to a central bank. During the First World War, governments released that bank from redeeming banknotes in gold and required everyone to accept them. Current accounts and checks added a last form: book money, created by commercial banks.
Quatre fonctions
The author defines money as anything that people use as an intermediary of exchange and as a standard of value, and that everyone accepts.
- Intermediary of exchange: you sell for money, then buy what you want.
- Standard of value: each good has a single price, as the meter measures lengths.
- Store of value: money keeps purchasing power for later. Gold, a building, or a stock do the same, but money can be spent without delay or loss: it is liquid.
- Means of deferred payment: it settles a sale on credit or a loan.
The Qur'an, the Sunna, and the scholars
The Qur'an names gold and silver, the two great currencies of history: the heaps of gold and silver (Āl ʿImrān, 14), the dinar entrusted (Āl ʿImrān, 75), the counted dirhams of Joseph's story (Yūsuf, 20), the silver coin of the People of the Cave (al-Kahf, 19). The Sunna sets the rules for exchanging them: “Gold for gold, silver for silver”; “Do not sell one dinar for two dinars, nor one dirham for two dirhams” (Muslim).
- Mālik: if people took hides as money, he would disapprove of selling them on deferred terms for gold or silver. The author infers that the rule follows monetary use, whatever the material.
- Al-Ghazālī: God created dinars and dirhams as “arbiters and intermediaries” between goods.
- Ibn Taymiyya: no one seeks the dirham for itself; it serves as a standard and a means of exchange, and usage defines it.
- Ibn al-Qayyim: money measures the value of goods; it must therefore remain stable, neither rising nor falling.
- Ibn Khaldūn: gold and silver give all goods their value and serve as a store, sheltered from market fluctuations.
The money of the Muslims
Before Islam, the Arabs used Byzantine gold dinars and Persian silver dirhams by weight. The Prophet confirmed the weights of Mecca (hadith reported by Abū Dāwūd and al-Nasā'ī, which al-Albānī judges authentic according to the author). ʿUmar fixed the weight of the dirham: seven dinars weigh as much as ten dirhams. Caliph ʿAbd al-Malik b. Marwān struck the first Islamic dinars between 74 and 76 AH and withdrew foreign coins.
After 247 AH, the debasement of dirhams appears: copper mixed with the silver, until only a tenth was left. Under the Mamluks, copper fulūs became the common currency. The Ottoman state issued a first paper money in 1862.
The banknote in Islamic law
Jurists have proposed four readings of the banknote.
- A debt instrument on its issuer.
- A commodity, since no one weighs or measures it.
- The equivalent of fulūs.
- The substitute for the gold or silver it replaces.
The Saudi Council of Senior Scholars ruled by majority in 1393 AH: the banknote is full money, and each currency forms a distinct genus. Three rules follow.
- Riba applies to it. You cannot exchange ten riyals for eleven riyals. You cannot exchange one currency for another on deferred terms. You can exchange two currencies at whatever rate you like, if each party hands over their sum on the spot.
- Zakat is due as soon as the sum reaches the lower of the two thresholds, the gold one or the silver one.
- The banknote can serve as capital in a partnership or in a salam contract.
Sources
- Dr. Saʿd b. Ḥamdān al-Luḥyānī, “Mabādi' al-iqtiṣād al-islāmī” (Principles of Islamic Economics), Umm al-Qurā University, 1428 AH, chapter 8, pp. 83-106 (Arabic text)
- Next installment: interest-based banking, Islamic banking
In the same section
- Foundations (1/6): what is Islamic economics? October 4, 2026
- Foundations (2/6): three systems, and the question of scarcity October 4, 2026
- Foundations (3/6): production, labor, land, capital, and risk October 4, 2026
- Foundations (4/6): how a price is formed October 4, 2026
- Foundations (6/6): interest-based banking, Islamic banking October 4, 2026
Read in the app · All articles
General information: neither investment advice nor a fatwa. Verdict calculated by published rules, from financial statements read automatically and not reviewed by a human. Read the methodology