Paying off a friend's car loan and reselling him the car at a markup: permitted?
Halal Bourse · October 13, 2026 · Contracts
No: the deal is a disguised interest-bearing loan. And if the seller keeps ownership until the last installment, the original sale is void. An account of IslamQA answer no. 433074 (January 2024), sources checked.
The website IslamQA, run by Sheikh Muḥammad Ṣāliḥ al-Munajjid, published answer no. 433074 on January 2, 2024, addressed to an installment seller. We give an account of it in our own words and have checked the two texts it cites.
The situation
A friend of the questioner bought a car on credit from an installment-sale company. He has paid part of the monthly installments, but the company refuses to hand over any ownership document, or even a power of attorney to drive the car, before the last payment. The original agreement said nothing of the kind. The friend therefore suggests that the questioner pay off the balance to the company, put the car in his own name, then resell it to him on credit at an agreed markup. The questioner asks whether the deal is permitted and in whose name the papers should be.
The car already belongs to the friend
From the moment of signing, a car bought on credit belongs to the buyer, even if the seller refuses to hand over the papers. If the contract states that ownership passes to the buyer only after the last installment, that clause is void and it voids the sale itself, because it contradicts the effect of the contract: a sale transfers ownership at the moment it is concluded.
The answer relies on resolution 51 (2/6) of the International Islamic Fiqh Academy (Jeddah, March 1990): the seller has no right to retain ownership of the good after the sale, but he may require that the good be pledged to him until the installments are paid. We found this passage on the Academy's website. The answer also cites al-Buhūtī, a Hanbali jurist who died in 1051 AH, in Kashshāf al-qināʿ (3/194): a sale made conditional on a future event is invalid, because a sale transfers ownership at the time of the exchange. We did not reopen that volume.
The friend's buyout is an interest-bearing loan
Since the car already belongs to the friend, the questioner cannot buy it from the company in order to resell it to him. Paying the money to the company on his behalf amounts to lending him the balance, which he then repays with a surcharge. Whether the money passes through his hands or goes straight to the company changes nothing: it is riba.
The permitted route
If the original contract contains the retention-of-title clause, it is void: the friend cancels it and recovers what he has paid. The questioner can then buy the car from the company, become its owner, and sell it to his friend on credit at a markup.
What you take from it
- Read, in a car-loan contract, who owns the car during repayment. Retention of title until the last installment contradicts the Academy's resolution; a pledge of the vehicle in the seller's favor is accepted.
- Paying off a relative's loan and then charging him a markup is an interest-bearing loan, whatever route the money takes.
- To resell on credit at a markup, you must have bought the good yourself and own it before selling it. Ibn Bāz reminded merchants of the same rule; see our article on credit sales.
- Under French law, a retention-of-title clause is valid (Civil Code, article 2367). The question addressed here is its religious compliance, not its legal validity.
Sources
- IslamQA, answer no. 433074 (Arabic text, January 2, 2024)
- International Islamic Fiqh Academy, resolution 51 (2/6) on installment sales, Jeddah, March 14-20, 1990 (Arabic text)
- Al-Buhūtī, Kashshāf al-qināʿ, 3/194 (cited by the answer, not reopened)
- Selling on credit for more than the cash price: Ibn Bāz's answer
In the same section
- Dropshipping: can you sell an item you do not own yet? Bandar al-Nimr's study October 18, 2026
- Selling on eBay an item that Amazon will deliver: permitted? IslamQA's answer October 18, 2026
- Is dropshipping permitted? The fatwa of Egypt's Dār al-Iftā October 18, 2026
- Halal dropshipping: which structure should you use? A marketing agency's guide October 18, 2026
- Muḍāraba: who earns what, who loses what? Sheikh Ferkous's fatwa October 18, 2026
- What is a muḍāraba contract, and under what conditions is it valid? October 18, 2026
Read in the app · All articles
General information: neither investment advice nor a fatwa. Verdict calculated by published rules, from financial statements read automatically and not reviewed by a human. Read the methodology