Halal Bourse

Home › Blog › Contracts

Selling on eBay an item that Amazon will deliver: permitted? IslamQA's answer

Halal Bourse · October 18, 2026 · Contracts

No, as long as you sell before you have bought and received the item; and a paid agency does not save the arrangement if you advance the money. An account of IslamQA's answer no. 289386 (October 2018), hadiths checked against the source.

The website IslamQA, run by Sheikh Muḥammad Ṣāliḥ al-Munajjid, published answer no. 289386 on October 16, 2018. The questioner knows the hadith “Do not sell what is not with you” and finds the site's previous answers too vague, so he describes his process in detail. We give an account of it in our own words, and we checked on sunnah.com the hadiths the answer cites.

The process described

He opens a store on eBay and lists clothes sold on Amazon, at a slightly higher price. A $10 jacket on Amazon becomes $12 on eBay. When a customer pays, eBay holds the $12; the seller buys the jacket on Amazon with his own money, has it delivered to the customer, and eBay releases the sum to him one week after delivery, the time left to the customer to return the item. The questioner insists: he does not buy with the customer's money, and the customer is protected against fraud.

Selling what you do not own

The answer states the rule: you do not sell what you do not own, except through a salam contract. Salam requires the seller to receive the price at the time of the contract. As long as the money stays blocked with the intermediary, the seller has not received it, and the salam does not hold (the answer refers to its answer no. 259320). It cites Maṭālib ūlī al-nuhā (3/20), a Ḥanbalī work: the sale of a specific object the seller does not own is void; the sale of a described thing is valid only if the price or the goods are received in the contract session, otherwise one sells a debt for a debt.

The founding text is the hadith of Ḥakīm b. Ḥizām, who asked the Prophet ﷺ whether he could sell a customer what he did not have, then buy it at the market: “Do not sell what is not with you.” Al-Nasā'ī (4613), Abū Dāwūd (3503) and al-Tirmidhī (1232) report it; al-Albānī grades it ṣaḥīḥ, al-Tirmidhī and the Dār al-Salām editors grade it ḥasan.

First way out: buy, receive, then sell

The answer allows murābaḥa for the one who orders the purchase: you agree with the customer that you will buy the item and resell it to him at a given markup. Two conditions. First, this agreement remains a promise that binds no one; you may ask for neither the price nor a deposit before the purchase, since a deposit would prove a commitment (answer no. 229091). Second, you must buy the item and receive it before concluding the sale with the customer. The answer relies on another version of Ḥakīm's hadith, “When you buy something, do not sell it before you have received it,” which it attributes to Aḥmad (15399) and al-Nasā'ī (4613) with al-Albānī's authentication (Ṣaḥīḥ al-Jāmiʿ, 342); on sunnah.com, al-Nasā'ī no. 4613 carries only the first version, and we did not check the second. It also cites the hadith of Zayd b. Thābit: the Prophet ﷺ forbade reselling goods where they are bought, before the merchants carry them to their own places (Abū Dāwūd 3499, ḥasan li-ghayrihi according to al-Albānī). Consequence: you cannot ask Amazon to ship to the customer. You, or an agent of yours, must receive the item; then you sell it.

Second way out: the paid agency, and why it fails here

You may also act as the customers' agent: you buy for them on Amazon, at Amazon's price without markup, for a commission, and with their money. In that case you need neither own nor receive the item, and Amazon delivers to the customer. But in the process described, the customer's money stays with eBay and you pay out of your own pocket. The price advanced becomes a loan from you to the customer, and you combine a loan with a paid service. The answer cites the decision of the Islamic Fiqh Council of the Muslim World League on margin trading (18th session, Mecca, April 2006): requiring the customer to go through the intermediary who lends to him amounts to combining a loan and an exchange, which the hadith “No loan combined with a sale” prohibits (Abū Dāwūd 3504, al-Tirmidhī 1234, ḥasan ṣaḥīḥ). The Council also recalls the jurists' rule that any loan that brings a benefit to the lender falls under riba.

The answer concludes: only the first way remains open to you, with its conditions.

What you take away

Sources

In the same section

Read in the app · All articles

General information: neither investment advice nor a fatwa. Verdict calculated by published rules, from financial statements read automatically and not reviewed by a human. Read the methodology