Is muḍāraba permitted, and how is profit shared? Judge al-ʿAmrānī's answers
Halal Bourse · October 18, 2026 · Contracts
Permitted by the evidence for agency and hiring; profit as the parties choose, loss on the investor unless the entrepreneur is at fault. An account of pages 194 to 197 of the collection Nayl al-amānī (Yemen), hadiths checked against the source.
Judge Muḥammad b. Ismāʿīl al-ʿAmrānī (1922-2021), a scholar from Yemen, had his answers collected in Nayl al-amānī. Volume 2, readable on the Shamela library, devotes its ninth chapter to partnership and muḍāraba. We give an account of pages 194 to 197 in our own words; we checked on sunnah.com the hadiths found there.
Did muḍāraba exist in the time of the Prophet ﷺ?
It existed before Islam and the Prophet ﷺ approved it. The judge adds that even supposing no specific text addresses it, it falls under the evidence for agency and hiring. For agency, he cites the People of the Cave sending one of them to buy food (18:19), Joseph having their goods returned to his brothers (12:62), ʿUrwa al-Bāriqī instructed to buy a sheep (al-Bukhārī 3642), ʿAlī instructed to give away as alms the covers and hides of the sacrificed animals (al-Bukhārī 2299), ʿUqba b. ʿĀmir instructed to distribute sheep (al-Bukhārī 2300). For hiring, paid breastfeeding (65:6), the pagan guide hired by the Prophet ﷺ and Abū Bakr during the emigration (al-Bukhārī 2263), the wall straightened by al-Khiḍr (18:77), the daughter of Madyan advising to hire Moses (28:26) and the reward promised for the king's cup (12:72).
He cites al-Shawkānī (Wabl al-ghamām): muḍāraba falls under “God has permitted sale and forbidden riba” and under the prohibition of consuming others' property without right; the owner of the money appoints another to buy and sell, and assigns him as wages a share of the profit; buying and selling fall under agency, the share of profit falls under hiring. He also cites Ibn Ḥajar: muḍāraba certainly existed in the time of the Prophet ﷺ, who knew of it and approved it, and Ḥakīm b. Ḥizām set conditions for the entrepreneur (no live animals, no sea, no torrent bed), failing which he guaranteed the money. We reopened neither work.
Why Islam permits it
One person owns money without being able, or without having the time, to make it grow; another has the skill without the money; each benefits from the other, money and work cooperate. The judge sees in it the best way to put Muslim capital to work, create jobs and avoid riba, and notes that Islamic banks rely on it. It remains permitted as long as it contains nothing prohibited (2:275; 7:157).
The practical questions
- May the entrepreneur take two thirds of the profit, the investor one third? Yes, as they choose: two thirds, one third, half or other, according to their agreement, by virtue of the verse on trade by consent (4:29) and the hadith according to which a man's property is lawful only with his full consent (reported by Aḥmad and al-Dāraquṭnī, which we did not check).
- May three or more people form a partnership with different stakes? Yes; the profit is shared in proportion to the stakes.
- One brings the money, the other the work? Yes, the profit according to their agreement. The loss falls on the investor, because the entrepreneur is an agent, an employee or a worker. Exception: if the investor set conditions (not to trade in vegetables, not to go to such a place) and the entrepreneur breached them, the entrepreneur is liable for the loss.
- Brothers who opened a second shop with their father's capital: an agreement binds those who concluded it or who appointed someone, by virtue of “Muslims are bound by their conditions” (al-Tirmidhī 1352, ḥasan ṣaḥīḥ, checked), but not the absent sisters; the division of the estate is done by fair arbitrators from both sides.
- Investment deposits in Islamic banks: the answer printed under this question speaks of a change of job and cites the verse on cooperation in sin (5:2); it seems to answer another question, and we do not use it.
What you take away
- The key to sharing: profit as the parties choose, loss on the capital, unless the entrepreneur is at fault.
- The conditions set by the investor (sector, place) bind the entrepreneur; breaching them shifts the loss onto him.
- In a partnership with several stakes, the share follows the stake.
- The hadith numbers printed in the book sometimes differ from sunnah.com's (ʿUrwa: 3770 in the book, 3642 on sunnah.com); we give sunnah.com's.
Sources
- Muḥammad b. Ismāʿīl al-ʿAmrānī, “Nayl al-amānī min fatāwā al-qāḍī,” volume 2, pp. 194-197 (Arabic text, Shamela library)
- Al-Bukhārī 3642 (ʿUrwa al-Bāriqī), 2299 (ʿAlī), 2300 (ʿUqba b. ʿĀmir), 2263 (the guide of the emigration); al-Tirmidhī 1352 (“Muslims are bound by their conditions”), checked on sunnah.com
- Al-Shawkānī, Wabl al-ghamām; Ibn Ḥajar, Fatḥ al-Bārī (cited by the judge, not reopened)
- Quran 18:19, 12:62, 65:6, 18:77, 28:26, 12:72, 2:275, 7:157, 4:29 and 5:2, text checked on quran.com
- Muḍāraba: who earns what, who loses what? Sheikh Ferkous's fatwa
- What is a muḍāraba contract, and under what conditions is it valid?
In the same section
- Dropshipping: can you sell an item you do not own yet? Bandar al-Nimr's study October 18, 2026
- Selling on eBay an item that Amazon will deliver: permitted? IslamQA's answer October 18, 2026
- Is dropshipping permitted? The fatwa of Egypt's Dār al-Iftā October 18, 2026
- Halal dropshipping: which structure should you use? A marketing agency's guide October 18, 2026
- Muḍāraba: who earns what, who loses what? Sheikh Ferkous's fatwa October 18, 2026
- What is a muḍāraba contract, and under what conditions is it valid? October 18, 2026
Read in the app · All articles
General information: neither investment advice nor a fatwa. Verdict calculated by published rules, from financial statements read automatically and not reviewed by a human. Read the methodology