Halal Bourse

Home › Blog › Contracts

Dropshipping: can you sell an item you do not own yet? Bandar al-Nimr's study

Halal Bourse · October 18, 2026 · Contracts

Yes for described goods, under the conditions of salam; no for a specific item the seller does not hold. An account of an eleven-page study published on Alukah in August 2024, hadiths checked against the source.

Bandar b. Saʿūd al-Nimr published an eleven-page study titled “The ruling on dropshipping” on the Saudi website Alukah on August 24, 2024. He presents it as the introduction to a broader work on the legal characterization of online stores: the fuḍūlī sale, immediate salam, the sale of an absent good, istiṣnāʿ, supply contracts. We give an account of it in our own words, and we checked on sunnah.com the hadiths he relies on.

What he calls dropshipping

A person lists items she does not own on her online store, with a markup. When a customer buys, she orders the item on another website, enters the customer's address there and keeps the price difference.

Three starting points

First case: described goods

The store lists a new phone, with the model, the manufacturer's photo, the specifications and the price, without designating a specific unit. The customer buys; the seller then sources that model from the supplier of his choice. The author sees this as the sale of a thing described “as a debt” (fī al-dhimma), deliverable without delay: an immediate salam (salam ḥāll). He holds this salam permitted, relying on ʿAṭā', al-Awzāʿī, al-Shāfiʿī and Abū Thawr, on one version of Aḥmad's view and on the choice of Ibn al-Mundhir. His reasoning: permission is the rule, no explicit text prohibits selling a described thing deliverable at once, and what is permitted on a deferred basis is permitted on the spot too.

He then answers the objection drawn from the hadith of Ḥakīm b. Ḥizām: “Do not sell what is not with you.” In his view, the chain of this version is broken, since Yūsuf b. Māhak did not hear from Ḥakīm; he cites Aḥmad and Ibn Ḥibbān. The version he holds reliable prohibits selling foodstuffs before receiving them. The reader should know that the collections give another assessment: al-Tirmidhī (1232) grades the hadith ḥasan and notes other chains of transmission, al-Albānī grades it ṣaḥīḥ in Abū Dāwūd (3503), and al-Nasā'ī (4613) reports it as well.

As for the hadith of ʿAbd Allāh b. ʿAmr, “No loan combined with a sale, no two conditions in one sale, no profit from what one does not guarantee, no sale of what is not with you” (Abū Dāwūd 3504, al-Tirmidhī 1234, ḥasan ṣaḥīḥ), the author applies it to the sale of a specific object the seller does not hold. He thus reconciles this text with the hadiths that permit salam (Ibn ʿAbbās: “Whoever pays in advance, let him do so for a known measure, a known weight, a known term,” al-Bukhārī 2240, Muslim 1604), with the account of ʿUrwa al-Bāriqī, who bought two sheep with the Prophet's ﷺ dinar and resold one (al-Bukhārī 3642), and with the Prophet's ﷺ purchase of a camel against measures of dates he did not hold in hand at the time of the contract (the account of Ṭāriq al-Muḥāribī reported by Ibn Ḥibbān, which we did not check).

The author's conclusion for this first case, which in his view is the most common: the sale is permitted, under the conditions of salam. He adds a rule on liability: the customer turns to the store that sold to him, not to the supplier. If the store writes in its terms that liability rests with the supplier, the sale stands and the clause falls, as in the hadith of Barīra, where the Prophet ﷺ declared void any condition absent from the Book of God (al-Bukhārī 2168).

Second case: a specific item

The store lists the photo of a used phone, a specific unit, which it does not own and which its owner has not authorized it to sell. After the order, it buys the phone on the owner's website and has it delivered to the customer. Here the author concludes that the sale is prohibited and void: the seller sells a specific object that is neither his, nor under his control, nor entrusted to him for sale. He cites Ibn Qudāma (al-Mughnī, 4/155): no one may sell a specific object he does not own in order to go and buy it afterwards and deliver it; this is al-Shāfiʿī's view, with no known dissent. The author rejects the comparison with the fuḍūlī sale, where an intermediary sells without a mandate and the sale depends on the owner's approval: in the accounts invoked, the goods were in the seller's hands, whereas the dropshipper has no hold on the item.

Three ways to regularize

What you take away

Sources

In the same section

Read in the app · All articles

General information: neither investment advice nor a fatwa. Verdict calculated by published rules, from financial statements read automatically and not reviewed by a human. Read the methodology