Is leasing halal? Sheikh Saʿd al-Khathlān's lesson
Halal Bourse · October 13, 2026 · Contracts
Neither yes nor no without reading the contract: a real lease with a promise of gift or sale is permitted, a sale disguised as a lease is prohibited. An account of a lesson by the Saudi sheikh, a former member of the Council of Senior Scholars, sources checked.
Saʿd b. Turkī al-Khathlān teaches fiqh at Imam Muḥammad b. Saʿūd University in Riyadh. He chairs the Saudi Fiqh Society, has sat on the Council of Senior Scholars and counts Ibn Bāz among his teachers. His website publishes the transcript of a lesson given in 1433 AH (2012) on leases ending in a transfer of ownership, the fifth lesson of his series on contemporary financial transactions. We give an account of it in our own words. We checked the hadiths he cites on sunnah.com and, on the website of the International Islamic Fiqh Academy, the resolution he discusses.
Why this contract divides scholars
The sheikh opens with a fact: the Council of Senior Scholars of Saudi Arabia examined this contract over three sessions, the 49th, 50th and 51st, and only ruled at the third, by majority. The difficulty lies in the hybrid nature of the arrangement. A sale transfers the good and its use, and the buyer bears its risks from the moment of conclusion. A lease transfers only the use; the good stays with the lessor, and the lessee answers for damage only in case of fault or negligence, what jurists call being a “trustee” (amīn). Leasing mixes the two regimes, hence the disagreement over how to classify it and what its ruling is.
The sheikh recalls the origin of the arrangement: it is said to have appeared in England in 1846 under the name hire purchase, then in the United States and France, before reaching Muslim countries. Companies found protection in it. In a credit sale, ownership passes to the buyer at once, and he can resell; in a lease, it stays with the lessor to the end.
The decision of the Council of Senior Scholars
At its 51st session, the Council, on which Ibn ʿUthaymīn then sat, ruled the contract prohibited, by majority, for three reasons the sheikh discusses.
- Two contracts on one good, with opposite effects. A sale places the good and its risks with the buyer; a lease leaves the risks with the lessor. The contract settles on neither.
- A rent that is not a rent. The example given: a good worth 50,000 riyals that rents for 1,000 riyals a month is “rented” for 2,000 a month, double, until the price is covered. If the lessee misses one payment, even the last, the lessor takes the good back and refunds nothing, on the grounds that the use has been consumed. The sheikh sees in this an injustice that drives people into debt to pay the last installment.
- A contract that pushes people of modest means into debt, to the point of exhausting their ability to pay and exposing creditors to bankruptcies.
The sheikh insists on the gravity of debt. He cites the hadith that death as a martyr wipes out everything except debt (al-Tirmidhī 1640; the compiler calls it gharīb, the Dār al-Salām editors grade it ṣaḥīḥ), verse 33 of Sūrat al-Nūr, which asks the one who cannot afford to marry to be patient, without telling him to borrow, and the account of the man with no dowry whom the Prophet ﷺ asks to look for “even an iron ring” before marrying him off for the sūras he knows (al-Bukhārī 5135, Muslim 1425).
The Academy's resolution, more complete
The sheikh prefers resolution 110 (4/12) of the International Islamic Fiqh Academy (Riyadh, September 2000), which he finds more precise: it distinguishes prohibited forms from permitted ones, where the Council described only the prohibited form. He restates its test. Prohibited: a sale and a lease concluded at the same time on the same good for the same period. Permitted: a real lease, followed by a sale contract concluded afterwards or accompanied by a promise of transfer at the end of the lease; the risks and major maintenance stay with the lessor, and insurance, if any, is cooperative and paid by him. We have summarized that resolution in a separate article.
His examples make the rule concrete. Permitted: “I lease you this car for three years and I promise, without binding myself, to give it to you if you pay every rent on time”; “I lease it to you for 2,000 riyals a month for two years and I promise to sell it to you for 10,000 at the end”; “you may buy it whenever you wish, through a new contract, at the market price of the day.” Prohibited: a lease that turns into a sale by itself at the last rent, a sale conditional on payment of all the rent, and a sale with an option in the lessor's sole favor.
“Halal or haram?” Read the contract
To the question put that way, the sheikh declines to answer: one must first know what the contract contains. He says he has read the contracts of Saudi car-sales companies drafted by jurists: the document is titled a lease contract and mentions no sale; the lessor assumes the warranty and maintenance; the insurance is cooperative and at his expense; a promise of gift closes the whole if the rents are paid. He recommends that any company using this arrangement have it drafted by a board of jurists, and recalls the hadith of the Khaybar dates: the Prophet ﷺ forbids exchanging two measures of ordinary dates for one of fine dates, and says to sell the former for dirhams and then buy the latter (al-Bukhārī 2201, Muslim 1593). Same result, two contracts, only one permitted.
Quatre clauses nulles
The sheikh points out four frequent clauses he considers worthless; they fall away, he says, without voiding the contract.
- An initial payment the lessor keeps as his due, although it is neither advance rent nor a security deposit.
- An obligation on the lessee to insure the good or to pay for its insurance, although the good belongs to the lessor.
- Liability of the lessee for all damage, even without fault or negligence.
- A final payment equal to the price of the good, demanded without a sale contract.
The pledge, a simpler solution
For the sheikh, the credit seller already has a security provided by the Qur'an: the pledge (rahn), in verse 283 of Sūrat al-Baqara. The Prophet ﷺ himself pledged his armor to a Jew of Medina for barley for his family (Ibn Mājah 2437; al-Bukhārī also reports this account). The seller sells the car for 50,000 riyals payable over two or three years and stipulates that it remains pledged for its price: the buyer owns it but cannot resell it before paying everything; if he stops paying, the seller has it sold, recovers his due and returns the surplus. The sheikh adopts the Mālikī view, under which the pledge binds from the contract without the creditor holding the good, against the majority of schools, which require delivery. He regrets that merchants import a foreign arrangement when their own law offers this solution.
Questions from the audience
- Difference from a credit sale: the credit buyer is the owner and can resell the next day; the lessee with a promise of transfer cannot, the good stays with the lessor.
- Islamic banks: judge each institution by the competence and rigor of its compliance board, and by the existence of independent oversight of how its decisions are applied.
- The promise of gift is not a trick if the lease is real; and if the lessee stops paying, the lessor takes the good back, as in any lease.
- Buying a car from someone who still holds it under a lease is prohibited: he does not own it. One must wait until the lessor has carried out his promise.
What you take from it
- Ask for the contract and look for the word sale: a real lease with a separate promise of gift or sale passes the test; an automatic switch into a sale at the last rent does not.
- Who pays for the insurance, major maintenance and no-fault damage? If you do, the contract treats you as the owner while denying you ownership.
- A non-refundable initial payment or a final payment equal to the price of the good are clauses the sheikh considers void.
- If you sell on credit, a pledge on the good sold protects your claim without any arrangement.
Sources
- Saʿd b. Turkī al-Khathlān, “al-Ta'jīr al-muntahī bi-l-tamlīk”, lesson 5 of the series Fiqh al-muʿāmalāt al-māliyya al-muʿāṣira (1433 AH), the sheikh's official website (Arabic text)
- International Islamic Fiqh Academy, resolution 110 (4/12), Riyadh, September 23-28, 2000 (official Arabic text)
- Jāmiʿ al-Tirmidhī 1640 (sunnah.com)
- Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī 5135 (sunnah.com)
- Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī 2201 (sunnah.com)
- Sunan Ibn Mājah 2437 (sunnah.com)
- Leasing and lease-to-own: the permitted and prohibited structures according to the Fiqh Academy
- Selling on credit for more than the cash price: Ibn Bāz's answer
In the same section
- Dropshipping: can you sell an item you do not own yet? Bandar al-Nimr's study October 18, 2026
- Selling on eBay an item that Amazon will deliver: permitted? IslamQA's answer October 18, 2026
- Is dropshipping permitted? The fatwa of Egypt's Dār al-Iftā October 18, 2026
- Halal dropshipping: which structure should you use? A marketing agency's guide October 18, 2026
- Muḍāraba: who earns what, who loses what? Sheikh Ferkous's fatwa October 18, 2026
- What is a muḍāraba contract, and under what conditions is it valid? October 18, 2026
Read in the app · All articles
General information: neither investment advice nor a fatwa. Verdict calculated by published rules, from financial statements read automatically and not reviewed by a human. Read the methodology