Halal Bourse

Home › Blog › Contracts

Speculating on currencies through a broker: permitted? The file of the Mawsūʿa al-muyassara

Halal Bourse · October 18, 2026 · Contracts

Two positions among contemporaries: permitted under the rules of exchange (the boards of Bank Albilad and Dubai Islamic Bank), prohibited for others; the OIC Academy rules out deferred settlement and promises of exchange. An account of question no. 150 of the encyclopedia, resolutions checked on the Academy's website.

The Mawsūʿa al-muyassara fī fiqh al-qaḍāyā al-muʿāṣira, a collective online encyclopedia written by a group of specialists, devotes its question no. 150 (April 20, 2021) to “muḍāraba in currencies”: the customer opens an account with a broker, buys and sells currencies thanks to a margin lent by the bank, and the broker charges fees on each transaction. We give an account of it in our own words, and we checked the Academy's two resolutions on its website.

Two tendencies among contemporaries

What the OIC Academy says

Resolution 63 (1/7), Jeddah, May 9-14, 1992, on financial markets: commodities are traded on organized markets in four ways. First: immediate delivery and payment, the goods or their title being in the seller's possession; permitted. Second: immediate delivery and payment made possible under the exchange's guarantee; permitted. Third: deferred delivery of a described thing, payment on delivery, with a clause of actual performance; prohibited, because both counter-values are deferred, unless the conditions of salam are met. Fourth: the same without a performance clause, the contract being closable by an opposite contract; the most common on the markets, prohibited. Currencies are traded only in the first two ways, under the rules of exchange; stock indexes are neither sold nor bought, because that is pure gambling on an imaginary thing.

Resolution 102 (5/11), Manama, November 14-19, 1998, on currency trading: the deferred sale of currencies is prohibited, as is the mutual promise of exchange, according to the Quran, the Sunna and consensus.

The two bank boards

Dubai Islamic Bank (fatwa 43): trading in currencies is permitted within the limits of ordinary supply and demand; it becomes prohibited when it turns into hoarding and exploitation, and the authorities may restrict it to avert harm (“neither harming nor reciprocating harm,” Ibn Mājah 2340 and 2341, chains graded weak one by one, hadith held strengthened by its routes). The board blames the fall of some countries' currencies on economic disorder and the interest-based system. Bank Albilad (decision 18): permitted on five conditions: exchange before the parties separate, actual or constructive; equality for the same currency, banknote for coin included; no option and no delay on either counter-value; no hoarding or harm; no transaction on the forward market.

What the encyclopedia does not say

What you take away

Sources

In the same section

Read in the app · All articles

General information: neither investment advice nor a fatwa. Verdict calculated by published rules, from financial statements read automatically and not reviewed by a human. Read the methodology